Moving further along in this, I can see that I need to be able to execute a Magento script upon failure of finding an image (particularly since many of these images are not being found due to being called by external references such as emails or other sites). I expect to use something like this from Apache to call this script that I'm hoping to get help on here:
# Inside of .htaccess: ###################### # if the file exists, just send it RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} -f RewriteRule ^cache/.*$ - [L] # if it doesn't exists, rewrite to PHP script RewriteCond %{REQUEST_FILENAME} !-f RewriteRule ^cache/.*$ /path/to/script.php?url=$0 [L]