Using Magento 1.91
If a user goes to any category page and clicks "All" in the toolbar, they will only see 3 products. This is not the case on the search pages, however, and clicking "All" there will show all products (and there are significantly more products in search than in the categories, so it's not a memory issue)
I've added different limits into the toolbar, 8, 12, 24 and those all work fine. The only issue is on "All"
I also removed the custom theme and I am still seeing the issue.
Any ideas on where to attack this? Thanks!