For some reason magento is subtracting the tax amount from the subtotal instead of adding it. 5.50 + 6.07 +0.66= 12.23 not 11.57.Grand total is wrong! I looked at my tax settings and they all seem correct so I have no idea why this is happening. Any help would be appreciated.
edit more pictures of config and settings The subtotal excluding tax is actually cheaper than the product thats 12.95!