I have configured Magento 1.9 as shown in picture. Display out of stock products to YES, and Qty for items status to become out of stock 4
The problem is, even though the quantity of a product is below 4, it still show as in stock with green texts. what did I miss?
Your issue might be due to your theme or your store settings.
If your theme doesn't handle stock status properly that could be causing that problem.
If these settings aren't on the proper store that could also be the cause of the issue.
I was able to get it to work with your exact settings.